
The Toronto Sun, May 9th, 1995. Page 5.
The damage comes from the left
It is the rallying cry of the post-Oklahoma City era - that
such a tragic bombing could happen here because there are violent
extremists in Canada, too, so we had all best be on guard against
the forces of darkness from the right.
This is the view of world best captured by the Toronto Star's
Michele Landsberg, who, in a recent column which happily marked
her return to physical, if not intellectual health, described
Canadian voices spouting "warmed-over versions of American
dogmas: Extreme individualism, attacks on immigration and
affirmative action, gun-mania, hatred of government, contempt for
victims.
"The kind of sick thinking that led to the Oklahoma bombing
has its breeding ground in this fever-swamp of tolerated
intolerance, racial bigotry and paranoia. There's a line of
connection, a continuum of hard views."
Well, shucks, there are extremists here, and even a history
of political violence, albeit a much more limited history than
America's, but the difference, overlooked by virtually everyone
who enters this discussion, is that in Canada, the tradition is
virtually all from the left.
From the sit-in at Sir George Williams University in Montreal
in 1969, when students led by such notables as black activist
Rosie Douglas and Liberal Sen. Anne Cools (who later received a
full pardon for her role in the nastiness) trashed the computers
and did $1.5 million worth of damage; to the kidnapping and
murder a year later of Pierre Laporte by the separatist FLQ; to
the bombing of Litton Systems in Toronto and the dynamiting of a
B.C. Hydro substation by the group called Direction Action to the
1993 trashing of white supremacist Gary Schipper's Toronto house,
the Canadian continuum of extreme action is almost exclusively
from the left of the political spectrum.
(The only acts in recent years that might be considered
exceptions are the arson at a Toronto abortion clinic and the
shooting of a Vancouver physician. In neither case has there
been an arrest, and abortion, I would argue in any cause, is such
a volatile issue it belongs in a loopy category of its own.)
This would appear to be the case in the torching, early last
Sunday morning, of the home and headquarters of Holocaust-denier
Ernst Zundel, though frankly, when one is swimming in these
increasingly muddied waters, nothing is for sure.
But early indications - video tape from cameras at the Zundel
residence, coupled with evidence from independant witnesses,
suggest that the man in the white cowboy hat who was seen
sprinkling gasoline about the building may well turn out not to
be a rightwing fanatic, but rather a leftwing one.
Certainly, Zundel and his Carlton St. headquarters have been
targets for years.
Most recently, he has been the particular favorite of a
strange little group called Cabbagetown Campaign Against Nazis in
Our Neighborhood - C-Canon, for short - which has a Toronto post
office box for a mailing address and a now-dysfunctional
telephone number.
Just two months ago, C-Canon was advertising a March 22
meeting called to deal with Zundel.
"Zundel in our neighborhood," the group's flyers read.
"Exposing a local hate monager. C-Canon presents a community
forum to find solutions to the problem of fascism in our
neighborhood." The flyers came complete with a map, pointing out
the location of "Zundel's bunker."
Even the condemnation of Sunday's arson sound luke-warm.
"It's an unfortunate, deplorable event," Louis Lenkinski of the
Canadian Jewish Congress told the Star. "That's not the way to
deal with people...no matter how distasteful the opponent."
What's that mean - the torching of Zundel's house is less
regrettable than, say, the torching of Lenkinski's house would
be?
Ernst Zundel is a distasteful fellow. His belief that the
Holocaust never happened is, to me, so beyond the pale it is
barely worthy of contempt. But he is not typical of the Canadian
fanatic, and his group is not typical of the Canadian political
extremist, and the blessedly limited tradition of bombings, and
violence, and destruction in Canada comes not the the likes of
Zundel, but rather from the smug and virtuous left.
* Read Christie Blatchford Tuesday through Friday
> Group says it torched Zundel house: page 30